10.3 candidates Test Results
See Tables below for CPU time/event [sec] with
7) 10.3.c02 with hadr-deex-V10-02-68
6) 10.3.c02 with hadr-deex-V10-02-67 + hadronic/models/de_excitation, pre_equilibrium, qmd of G4 10.2.p02
5) 10.3.c02 with hadr-deex-V10-02-68 + hadronic/models/parton_string of G4 10.2.ref10
4) 10.3.c01 with hadr-deex-V10-02-65
3) 10.3.c00 with hadr-deex-V10-02-62
2) 10.3.c00 with hadr-deex-V10-02-59
1) 10.3.c01 with phys-ctor-hinelastic-v10-02-06
Legend:
c0268 = 10.3.c02 + hadr-deex-V10-02-68
c02t2 = 10.3.c02 + hadr-deex-V10-02-67 + hadronic/models/de_excitation, pre_equilibrium, qmd of G4 10.2.p02
c02t1 = 10.3.c02 + hadr-deex-V10-02-68 + hadronic/models/parton_string of G4 10.2.ref10
deex65 = 10.3.c01 + hadr-deex-V10-02-65
deex62 = 10.3.c00 + hadr-deex-V10-02-62
deex59 = 10.3.c00 + hadr-deex-V10-02-59
hi06 = 10.3.c01 + phys-ctor-hinelastic-v10-02-06
Table 6) 10.3.c02 + hadr-deex-V10-02-67 + hadronic/models/de_excitation, pre_equilibrium, qmd of G4 10.2.p02
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 10.3.c02 10.3c02t2 100*(c02t2-c02)/c02 sample
#
# mean error mean error %diff error
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
320.7700 1.4388 321.6400 1.2678 0.3 0.6 higgs.FTFP_BERT.1400.4
0.0170 0.0002 0.0169 0.0001 -0.6 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.0855 0.0008 0.0851 0.0008 -0.5 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.1713 0.0015 0.1703 0.0016 -0.6 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
0.8416 0.0091 0.8398 0.0087 -0.2 1.5 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0216 0.0002 0.0220 0.0001 1.9 1.1 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1086 0.0008 0.1105 0.0008 1.7 1.1 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2174 0.0016 0.2210 0.0015 1.7 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.0754 0.0078 1.0930 0.0071 1.6 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0276 0.0002 0.0269 0.0002 -2.5 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.1233 0.0009 0.1216 0.0009 -1.4 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.2337 0.0017 0.2309 0.0017 -1.2 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
1.0564 0.0091 1.0433 0.0088 -1.2 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0306 0.0002 0.0300 0.0002 -2.0 0.9 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1384 0.0009 0.1371 0.0010 -0.9 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2643 0.0018 0.2623 0.0018 -0.8 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2230 0.0071 1.2208 0.0076 -0.2 0.8 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0306 0.0002 0.0300 0.0002 -2.0 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BERT.1.4
0.1357 0.0009 0.1334 0.0009 -1.7 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BERT.5.4
0.2646 0.0018 0.2608 0.0019 -1.4 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BERT.10.4
1.2182 0.0069 1.2076 0.0077 -0.9 0.8 pi-.QGSP_BERT.50.4
0.0266 0.0002 0.0260 0.0002 -2.3 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.1.4
0.1245 0.0009 0.1258 0.0008 1.0 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BIC.5.4
0.2414 0.0017 0.2445 0.0017 1.3 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BIC.10.4
1.1294 0.0073 1.1439 0.0070 1.3 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BIC.50.4
0.0709 0.0005 0.0734 0.0006 3.5 1.1 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1809 0.0014 0.1797 0.0012 -0.7 1.0 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.3092 0.0023 0.3060 0.0022 -1.0 1.0 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2918 0.0077 1.2830 0.0069 -0.7 0.8 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0231 0.0002 0.0225 0.0001 -2.6 0.9 proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1357 0.0009 0.1333 0.0009 -1.8 0.9 proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2673 0.0018 0.2636 0.0018 -1.4 0.9 proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2593 0.0083 1.2478 0.0080 -0.9 0.9 proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0890 0.0006 0.0917 0.0005 3.0 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3098 0.0018 0.3148 0.0017 1.6 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.5460 0.0037 0.5577 0.0033 2.1 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.7779 0.0054 0.7989 0.0045 2.7 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.0706 0.0005 0.0729 0.0004 3.3 0.9 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3497 0.0024 0.3606 0.0022 3.1 0.9 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.6373 0.0044 0.6509 0.0038 2.1 0.9 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.9021 0.0056 0.9278 0.0046 2.8 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 5) 10.3.c02 + hadr-deex-V10-02-68 + hadronic/models/parton_string of G4 10.2.ref10
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#
# 10.3.c02 10.3c02t1 100*(c02t1-c02)/c02 sample
#
# mean error mean error %diff error
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
320.7700 1.4388 311.0900 1.3016 -3.0 0.6 higgs.FTFP_BERT.1400.4
0.0170 0.0002 0.0162 0.0001 -4.7 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.0855 0.0008 0.0814 0.0007 -4.8 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.1713 0.0015 0.1626 0.0014 -5.1 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
0.8416 0.0091 0.8016 0.0083 -4.8 1.4 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0216 0.0002 0.0212 0.0002 -1.9 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1086 0.0008 0.1067 0.0008 -1.7 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2174 0.0016 0.2132 0.0016 -1.9 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.0754 0.0078 1.0537 0.0082 -2.0 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0276 0.0002 0.0276 0.0002 0.0 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.1233 0.0009 0.1163 0.0009 -5.7 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.2337 0.0017 0.2168 0.0017 -7.2 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
1.0564 0.0091 0.9934 0.0089 -6.0 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0306 0.0002 0.0309 0.0002 1.0 0.9 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1384 0.0009 0.1335 0.0010 -3.5 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2643 0.0018 0.2520 0.0019 -4.7 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2230 0.0071 1.1843 0.0078 -3.2 0.9 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0306 0.0002 0.0310 0.0003 1.3 1.2 pi-.QGSP_BERT.1.4
0.1357 0.0009 0.1366 0.0010 0.7 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BERT.5.4
0.2646 0.0018 0.2594 0.0019 -2.0 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BERT.10.4
1.2182 0.0069 1.1649 0.0087 -4.4 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BERT.50.4
0.0266 0.0002 0.0266 0.0002 0.0 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.1.4
0.1245 0.0009 0.1189 0.0008 -4.5 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BIC.5.4
0.2414 0.0017 0.2295 0.0017 -4.9 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BIC.10.4
1.1294 0.0073 1.0653 0.0077 -5.7 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BIC.50.4
0.0709 0.0005 0.0701 0.0006 -1.1 1.1 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1809 0.0014 0.1739 0.0013 -3.9 1.0 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.3092 0.0023 0.2975 0.0023 -3.8 1.0 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2918 0.0077 1.2488 0.0087 -3.3 0.9 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0231 0.0002 0.0234 0.0002 1.3 1.2 proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1357 0.0009 0.1332 0.0010 -1.8 1.0 proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2673 0.0018 0.2566 0.0019 -4.0 1.0 proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2593 0.0083 1.2232 0.0088 -2.9 0.9 proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0890 0.0006 0.0890 0.0007 0.0 1.0 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3098 0.0018 0.3088 0.0019 -0.3 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.5460 0.0037 0.5444 0.0041 -0.3 1.0 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.7779 0.0054 0.7786 0.0055 0.1 1.0 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.0706 0.0005 0.0703 0.0005 -0.4 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3497 0.0024 0.3499 0.0023 0.1 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.6373 0.0044 0.6339 0.0048 -0.5 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.9021 0.0056 0.8986 0.0061 -0.4 0.9 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 4) 10.3.c01 + hadr-deex-V10-02-65
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 10.3.c00 c01+deex65 100*(deex65-c00)/c00 sample
#
# mean error mean error %diff error
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
308.7700 1.9957 327.3700 1.7143 6.0 0.9 higgs.FTFP_BERT.1400.4
0.0167 0.0002 0.0174 0.0001 4.2 1.4 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.0833 0.0008 0.0872 0.0008 4.7 1.4 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.1661 0.0015 0.1741 0.0013 4.8 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
0.8212 0.0099 0.8589 0.0075 4.6 1.6 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0213 0.0002 0.0224 0.0002 5.2 1.4 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1074 0.0009 0.1122 0.0009 4.5 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2145 0.0017 0.2250 0.0018 4.9 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.0578 0.0074 1.1096 0.0079 4.9 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0260 0.0003 0.0276 0.0002 6.2 1.4 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.1170 0.0010 0.1219 0.0010 4.2 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.2194 0.0018 0.2346 0.0019 6.9 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
1.0047 0.0109 1.0568 0.0093 5.2 1.5 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0286 0.0003 0.0308 0.0002 7.7 1.3 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1295 0.0011 0.1379 0.0010 6.5 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2498 0.0019 0.2663 0.0021 6.6 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.1650 0.0091 1.2443 0.0084 6.8 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0285 0.0003 0.0308 0.0002 8.1 1.3 pi-.QGSP_BERT.1.4
0.1279 0.0012 0.1369 0.0010 7.0 1.3 pi-.QGSP_BERT.5.4
0.2501 0.0020 0.2665 0.0019 6.6 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BERT.10.4
1.1625 0.0102 1.2320 0.0079 6.0 1.2 pi-.QGSP_BERT.50.4
0.0238 0.0002 0.0268 0.0002 12.6 1.3 pi-.QGSP_BIC.1.4
0.1136 0.0008 0.1258 0.0009 10.7 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.5.4
0.2215 0.0016 0.2441 0.0018 10.2 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.10.4
1.0604 0.0074 1.1486 0.0078 8.3 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.50.4
0.0671 0.0007 0.0719 0.0006 7.2 1.4 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1704 0.0015 0.1821 0.0014 6.9 1.2 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2922 0.0024 0.3128 0.0023 7.0 1.2 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2267 0.0108 1.3098 0.0081 6.8 1.1 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0215 0.0002 0.0232 0.0002 7.9 1.4 proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1272 0.0010 0.1357 0.0010 6.7 1.1 proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2495 0.0020 0.2688 0.0020 7.7 1.2 proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.1860 0.0094 1.2701 0.0079 7.1 1.1 proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0857 0.0005 0.0892 0.0008 4.1 1.1 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.2988 0.0017 0.3075 0.0027 2.9 1.1 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.5325 0.0030 0.5479 0.0049 2.9 1.1 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.7471 0.0042 0.7841 0.0057 5.0 1.0 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.0680 0.0004 0.0710 0.0006 4.4 1.1 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3409 0.0020 0.3514 0.0027 3.1 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.6185 0.0033 0.6394 0.0050 3.4 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.8822 0.0050 0.9099 0.0073 3.1 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.1608 0.0005 0.1617 0.0009 0.6 0.6 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.1.4
0.8653 0.0021 0.8799 0.0059 1.7 0.7 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.5.4
0.1694 0.0010 0.1694 0.0007 0.0 0.7 proton.Shielding.1.4
0.9251 0.0025 0.9363 0.0044 1.2 0.5 proton.Shielding.5.4
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 3) 10.3.c00 + hadr-deex-V10-02-62
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 10.3.c00 c00+deex62 100*(deex62-c00)/c00 sample
#
# mean error mean error %diff error
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
308.7700 1.9957 319.4100 1.5026 3.4 0.8 higgs.FTFP_BERT.1400.4
0.0167 0.0002 0.0168 0.0001 0.6 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.0833 0.0008 0.0841 0.0008 1.0 1.4 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.1661 0.0015 0.1677 0.0013 1.0 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
0.8212 0.0099 0.8284 0.0082 0.9 1.6 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0213 0.0002 0.0216 0.0002 1.4 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1074 0.0009 0.1083 0.0008 0.8 1.1 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2145 0.0017 0.2167 0.0018 1.0 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.0578 0.0074 1.0700 0.0095 1.2 1.1 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0260 0.0003 0.0273 0.0002 5.0 1.4 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.1170 0.0010 0.1220 0.0010 4.3 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.2194 0.0018 0.2295 0.0019 4.6 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
1.0047 0.0109 1.0412 0.0091 3.6 1.4 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0286 0.0003 0.0306 0.0003 7.0 1.5 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1295 0.0011 0.1374 0.0011 6.1 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2498 0.0019 0.2615 0.0020 4.7 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.1650 0.0091 1.2184 0.0093 4.6 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0285 0.0003 0.0306 0.0003 7.4 1.5 pi-.QGSP_BERT.1.4
0.1279 0.0012 0.1354 0.0011 5.9 1.3 pi-.QGSP_BERT.5.4
0.2501 0.0020 0.2636 0.0021 5.4 1.2 pi-.QGSP_BERT.10.4
1.1625 0.0102 1.2128 0.0086 4.3 1.2 pi-.QGSP_BERT.50.4
0.0238 0.0002 0.0263 0.0002 10.5 1.3 pi-.QGSP_BIC.1.4
0.1136 0.0008 0.1232 0.0009 8.5 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.5.4
0.2215 0.0016 0.2398 0.0018 8.3 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.10.4
1.0604 0.0074 1.1253 0.0084 6.1 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.50.4
0.0671 0.0007 0.0705 0.0007 5.1 1.5 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1704 0.0015 0.1806 0.0015 6.0 1.3 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2922 0.0024 0.3089 0.0025 5.7 1.2 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2267 0.0108 1.2836 0.0090 4.6 1.2 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0215 0.0002 0.0231 0.0002 7.4 1.4 proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1272 0.0010 0.1354 0.0011 6.4 1.2 proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2495 0.0020 0.2675 0.0022 7.2 1.2 proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.1860 0.0094 1.2481 0.0091 5.2 1.1 proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0857 0.0005 0.0886 0.0005 3.4 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.2988 0.0017 0.3031 0.0019 1.4 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.5325 0.0030 0.5465 0.0035 2.6 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.7471 0.0042 0.7807 0.0049 4.5 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.0680 0.0004 0.0709 0.0004 4.3 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3409 0.0020 0.3533 0.0026 3.6 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.6185 0.0033 0.6386 0.0039 3.2 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.8822 0.0050 0.9075 0.0068 2.9 1.0 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.1608 0.0005 0.1601 0.0006 -0.4 0.5 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.1.4
0.8653 0.0021 0.8654 0.0039 0.0 0.5 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.5.4
0.1694 0.0010 0.1680 0.0006 -0.8 0.7 proton.Shielding.1.4
0.9251 0.0025 0.9257 0.0035 0.1 0.5 proton.Shielding.5.4
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 2) 10.3.c00 + hadr-deex-V10-02-59
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 10.3.c00 c00+deex59 100*(deex59-c00)/c00 sample
#
# mean error mean error %diff error
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
308.7700 1.9957 316.7800 1.5194 2.6 0.8 higgs.FTFP_BERT.1400.4
0.0167 0.0002 0.0166 0.0001 -0.6 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.0833 0.0008 0.0834 0.0007 0.1 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.1661 0.0015 0.1668 0.0013 0.4 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
0.8212 0.0099 0.8227 0.0072 0.2 1.5 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0213 0.0002 0.0214 0.0002 0.5 1.3 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1074 0.0009 0.1074 0.0008 0.0 1.1 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2145 0.0017 0.2150 0.0016 0.2 1.1 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.0578 0.0074 1.0623 0.0081 0.4 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0260 0.0003 0.0272 0.0002 4.6 1.4 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.1170 0.0010 0.1215 0.0010 3.8 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.2194 0.0018 0.2288 0.0018 4.3 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
1.0047 0.0109 1.0313 0.0088 2.6 1.4 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0286 0.0003 0.0304 0.0003 6.3 1.5 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1295 0.0011 0.1366 0.0011 5.5 1.2 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2498 0.0019 0.2611 0.0020 4.5 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.1650 0.0091 1.2121 0.0090 4.0 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0285 0.0003 0.0303 0.0003 6.3 1.5 pi-.QGSP_BERT.1.4
0.1279 0.0012 0.1348 0.0011 5.4 1.3 pi-.QGSP_BERT.5.4
0.2501 0.0020 0.2619 0.0019 4.7 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BERT.10.4
1.1625 0.0102 1.2044 0.0097 3.6 1.2 pi-.QGSP_BERT.50.4
0.0238 0.0002 0.0261 0.0002 9.7 1.2 pi-.QGSP_BIC.1.4
0.1136 0.0008 0.1228 0.0009 8.1 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.5.4
0.2215 0.0016 0.2373 0.0018 7.1 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.10.4
1.0604 0.0074 1.1175 0.0071 5.4 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BIC.50.4
0.0671 0.0007 0.0703 0.0006 4.8 1.4 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1704 0.0015 0.1797 0.0015 5.5 1.3 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2922 0.0024 0.3076 0.0026 5.3 1.2 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2267 0.0108 1.2774 0.0085 4.1 1.1 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0215 0.0002 0.0230 0.0002 7.0 1.4 proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1272 0.0010 0.1345 0.0010 5.7 1.1 proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2495 0.0020 0.2643 0.0020 5.9 1.2 proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.1860 0.0094 1.2421 0.0093 4.7 1.1 proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0857 0.0005 0.0876 0.0004 2.2 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.2988 0.0017 0.3023 0.0017 1.2 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.5325 0.0030 0.5467 0.0028 2.7 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.7471 0.0042 0.7723 0.0050 3.4 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.0680 0.0004 0.0690 0.0004 1.5 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3409 0.0020 0.3477 0.0024 2.0 0.9 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.6185 0.0033 0.6346 0.0039 2.6 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.8822 0.0050 0.8962 0.0055 1.6 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.1608 0.0005 0.1601 0.0009 -0.4 0.6 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.1.4
0.8653 0.0021 0.8702 0.0046 0.6 0.6 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.5.4
0.1694 0.0010 0.1688 0.0006 -0.4 0.7 proton.Shielding.1.4
0.9251 0.0025 0.9254 0.0035 0.0 0.5 proton.Shielding.5.4
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 1) 10.3.c01 + phys-ctor-hinelastic-v10-02-06
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
# 10.3.c01 10.3c01-hi06 100*(c01hi06-c01)/c01 sample
#
# mean error mean error %diff error
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------
325.0100 1.3350 333.0000 1.3273 2.5 0.6 higgs.FTFP_BERT.1400.4
0.0170 0.0001 0.0175 0.0001 2.9 0.8 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.0851 0.0007 0.0877 0.0007 3.1 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.1702 0.0014 0.1751 0.0015 2.9 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
0.8397 0.0066 0.8662 0.0079 3.2 1.2 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0220 0.0002 0.0225 0.0001 2.3 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1106 0.0008 0.1130 0.0007 2.2 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2210 0.0015 0.2262 0.0016 2.4 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.0949 0.0078 1.1197 0.0071 2.3 1.0 e-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0274 0.0002 0.0282 0.0002 2.9 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.0
0.1212 0.0009 0.1260 0.0010 4.0 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.0
0.2314 0.0018 0.2368 0.0019 2.3 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.0
1.0507 0.0085 1.0780 0.0083 2.6 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.0
0.0309 0.0002 0.0316 0.0002 2.3 0.9 pi-.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1376 0.0011 0.1423 0.0010 3.4 1.1 pi-.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2644 0.0019 0.2703 0.0018 2.2 1.0 pi-.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2331 0.0081 1.2656 0.0077 2.6 0.9 pi-.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0309 0.0002 0.0316 0.0002 2.3 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BERT.1.4
0.1371 0.0011 0.1406 0.0010 2.6 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BERT.5.4
0.2670 0.0021 0.2735 0.0019 2.4 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BERT.10.4
1.2299 0.0075 1.2585 0.0077 2.3 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BERT.50.4
0.0267 0.0002 0.0272 0.0002 1.9 1.1 pi-.QGSP_BIC.1.4
0.1253 0.0009 0.1277 0.0008 1.9 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BIC.5.4
0.2438 0.0017 0.2487 0.0015 2.0 0.9 pi-.QGSP_BIC.10.4
1.1484 0.0085 1.1723 0.0078 2.1 1.0 pi-.QGSP_BIC.50.4
0.0715 0.0006 0.0731 0.0006 2.2 1.2 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1820 0.0014 0.1867 0.0014 2.6 1.1 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.3115 0.0024 0.3197 0.0023 2.6 1.1 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.3040 0.0083 1.3348 0.0074 2.4 0.9 anti_proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0234 0.0002 0.0240 0.0002 2.6 1.2 proton.FTFP_BERT.1.4
0.1345 0.0011 0.1403 0.0010 4.3 1.1 proton.FTFP_BERT.5.4
0.2688 0.0021 0.2762 0.0018 2.8 1.0 proton.FTFP_BERT.10.4
1.2655 0.0088 1.2974 0.0078 2.5 0.9 proton.FTFP_BERT.50.4
0.0865 0.0004 0.0879 0.0004 1.6 0.7 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.2970 0.0018 0.3026 0.0018 1.9 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.5370 0.0030 0.5480 0.0032 2.0 0.8 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.7665 0.0046 0.7805 0.0047 1.8 0.9 pi-.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.0689 0.0003 0.0699 0.0004 1.5 0.7 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.1.4
0.3443 0.0017 0.3508 0.0020 1.9 0.8 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.5.4
0.6239 0.0029 0.6351 0.0036 1.8 0.7 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.10.4
0.8857 0.0046 0.9025 0.0045 1.9 0.7 proton.FTFP_INCLXX.15.4
0.1621 0.0007 0.1616 0.0007 -0.3 0.6 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.1.4
0.8784 0.0050 0.8752 0.0055 -0.4 0.8 proton.FTFP_BERT_HP.5.4
0.1701 0.0006 0.1696 0.0005 -0.3 0.5 proton.Shielding.1.4
0.9410 0.0049 0.9354 0.0049 -0.6 0.7 proton.Shielding.5.4
#------------------------------------------------------------------------------